What’s the first candy you’re sneaking from your kid’s trick-or-treat stash? Whether it’s for you or not, dentists suggest you might want to nab a few specific ones out first — at least to save those teeth! They’re warning against handing over hard candies like Jolly Ranchers or Life Savers, since they’re prime suspects for chipping a tooth, and no one wants that pain (or the dentist bill that comes with it).

I’ll stick to Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups myself! Sure, it’s maybe not ideal to grab a box for the kids and a box for me, but I’ll take the slow decay over a quick break any day.